DAFC.net Forum

Forum List | Football Forum

Topic: PFA Championship team of the year
1. Author: GJS93 Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 12:14 places for JCM and Fraser. 𝗩𝗼𝘁𝗲𝗱 𝗳𝗼𝗿 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗽𝗹𝗮𝘆𝗲𝗿𝘀, 𝗯𝘆 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗽𝗹𝗮𝘆𝗲𝗿𝘀. Here is your PFA Scotland Championship Team of the Year for 25/26, sponsored by @1stClassCU . Toby Steward (St Johnstone) Ben McPherson (Partick Thistle) Jeremiah Chilokoa-Mullen (Dunfermline Athletic) Cheick Diabate (St Johnstone) Robbie Fraser (Dunfermline Athletic) Ben Stanway (Partick Thistle) Reece McAlear (St Johnstone) Jason Holt (St Johnstone) Jamie Gullan (St Johnstone) Alex Samuel (Partick Thistle) Josh McPake (St Johnstone) Reply
2. Author: veteraneastender Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 12:18 Both our players have been consistent performers all season - getting Fraser on a three year deal was really a good piece of business. Reply
3. Author: Jeffery Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 12:24 Maybe a little surprised by Samuel (maybe a bit of recency bias?) but otherwise seems fair. Andrew Tod has scored more goals in less minutes... Robbie Fraser is the best left back in the division. Reply
4. Author: king lad Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 12:29 Yeah Samuel is the only one that seems a bit odd. Fowler or Tod have both been better over the course of the season imo Reply
5. Author: shellypar Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 12:41 BouncyPar wont be happy COYP Reply
6. Author: BouncyPar Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 12:55 shellypar, Fri 17 Apr 12:41 BouncyPar wont be happy I said in my post there will be many who disagree with me, and that`s absolutely fine. Football is all about opinions and viewpoints. I stand by my opinion of what I`ve seen of JCM, however I equally bow to the knowledge of others and respect everyone else`s opinions. Do I rate him? Nope. Do I want the best for the Pars? 100%. Do I hope I`m wrong, and he plays a blinder tomorrow? Absolutely. Eta I'm probably wrong with my assessment of JCM, I accept that. I'll pay closer attention to him, and maybe (hopefully) my opinion will change. Either way, it would be a sad world if we all agreed on everything 🏁 Post Edited (Fri 17 Apr 12:58) Reply
7. Author: shellypar Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 13:15 BouncyPar, Fri 17 Apr 12:55 shellypar, Fri 17 Apr 12:41 BouncyPar wont be happy I said in my post there will be many who disagree with me, and that`s absolutely fine. Football is all about opinions and viewpoints. I stand by my opinion of what I`ve seen of JCM, however I equally bow to the knowledge of others and respect everyone else`s opinions. Do I rate him? Nope. Do I want the best for the Pars? 100%. Do I hope I`m wrong, and he plays a blinder tomorrow? Absolutely. Eta I`m probably wrong with my assessment of JCM, I accept that. I`ll pay closer attention to him, and maybe (hopefully) my opinion will change. Either way, it would be a sad world if we all agreed on everything 🏁 No i agree about opinions n stuff, but i just dont understand how u come to that conclusion about JCM tbh COYP Reply
8. Author: Sacktheref69 Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 13:28 Embarrassing that the second highest scorer in the league isn`t in the team but 2 strikers with 4 less goals gets in? No place for Gilmour or A. Tod is a war crime. This is Andy Tod`s world and we are lucky to live in it. Reply
9. Author: ReturningParsFan Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 13:31 Another vote for Gilmour, definitely one of the top midfielders in the league. Maybe a few more goals or assists would have helped. Reply
10. Author: veteraneastender Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 14:19 Peer group polls of players are more reliable than those of fans IMO.....the award is not a local popularity result. Reply
11. Author: AdamAntsParsStripe Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 14:21 Jeffery, Fri 17 Apr 12:24 Maybe a little surprised by Samuel (maybe a bit of recency bias?) but otherwise seems fair. Andrew Tod has scored more goals in less minutes... Robbie Fraser is the best left back in the division. Agree about Fraser. I know many were surprised we got him full time but in an interview, he said Russell Martin advised him he wasn’t part of Rangers plans and it was a no brainer to sign the deal. Great business from us. We can’t really argue about the choices as it was fellow players who voted and that’s a high accolade in itself if chosen. Zwei Pints Bier und ein Päckchen Chips bitte Reply
12. Author: wee eck Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 14:45 6 from SJ, 3 from PT and 2 from DA hardly supports the claim that the Championship is a very competitive league. I wouldn`t say Steward, McPherson and Diabate were outstanding in their positions and a few others are debatable too. Reply
13. Author: summeragent Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 15:17 BouncyPar, Fri 17 Apr 12:55 shellypar, Fri 17 Apr 12:41 BouncyPar wont be happy I said in my post there will be many who disagree with me, and that`s absolutely fine. Football is all about opinions and viewpoints. I stand by my opinion of what I`ve seen of JCM, however I equally bow to the knowledge of others and respect everyone else`s opinions. Do I rate him? Nope. Do I want the best for the Pars? 100%. Do I hope I`m wrong, and he plays a blinder tomorrow? Absolutely. Eta I`m probably wrong with my assessment of JCM, I accept that. I`ll pay closer attention to him, and maybe (hopefully) my opinion will change. Either way, it would be a sad world if we all agreed on everything 🏁 Post Edited (Fri 17 Apr 12:58) I really don’t understand how you don’t rate him? I get everyone has their opinion but the guy is amazing when on his game and that’s more often than not. The fact that he is selected for Scotland u21s also gives some clues!! What is it that you think is missing in his game? Reply
14. Author: red-star-par Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 17:53 I agree with AAPS above, it`s the players that are voting, they will have faced these guys on the pitch 4 times a season - they`ll know. Gilmour is a good player but those 3 midfielders are better. If we do have a warchest for next season we should be getting that Stanway signed up Reply
15. Author: wee eck Date: Fri 17th Apr 2026. 23:05 5 Hearts players, 4 from M`well and one each from Celtic and Rangers are in the PFA Premiership team of the year. Reply

Post your Reply

Your Message:

By using your account you have implicitly accepted the DAFC.net Forum Rules and agree to be bound by them. You also agree that you will take sole responsibility for your post and indemnify dafc.net on all matters and costs. Refrain from making any potentially libelous comments about anyone

- - -