DAFC.net
Login:

password:  
  



Forum List | Football Forum

     [ 1 ] -- 2 --      

Topic: Appeal
1. Author:  SeasonedPar        
Date: Mon 3rd Mar 2025. 15:50

Club to appeal Bene’s red card. Appeal to be heard tomorrow, Tuesday.

Looks pretty straightforward to me, ball before man and should be rescinded.

Reply
2. Author:  Ahoy!Ahoy!        
Date: Mon 3rd Mar 2025. 16:27

Surely it’ll be rescinded. Looked a good tackle at the time and again on replays.



Reply
3. Author:  parsmad68        
Date: Mon 3rd Mar 2025. 16:30

Hope he gets the appeal. I thought he did well to remain as calm as he did given the time of the game and the pressure he knew this would inflict upon the team at a time of ascendancy. Hats off for him when he just turned and walked away after the initial obvious rant.. I am not sure how many other players would have been so calm.

Reply
4. Author:  pars no1        
Date: Mon 3rd Mar 2025. 16:31

you can always tell by a players reaction to these things. H could not believe it at the time which leads you to think he clearly got the ball first. Downgraded to a yellow at worst should be the outcome.



Reply
5. Author:  fcda        
Date: Mon 3rd Mar 2025. 17:34

pars no1, Mon 3 Mar 16:31

you can always tell by a players reaction to these things. H could not believe it at the time which leads you to think he clearly got the ball first. Downgraded to a yellow at worst should be the outcome.


Surely if it`s any kind of foul, it`s a red, so either it`s completely [s]reminded[/s] recinded or it stands?

Post Edited (Mon 03 Mar 22:26)

Reply
6. Author:  GG Riva        
Date: Mon 3rd Mar 2025. 17:44

fcda, Mon 3 Mar 17:34

pars no1, Mon 3 Mar 16:31

you can always tell by a players reaction to these things. H could not believe it at the time which leads you to think he clearly got the ball first. Downgraded to a yellow at worst should be the outcome.


Surely if it`s any kind of foul, it`s a red, so either it`s completely reminded or it stands?


This. It`s either a foul and a red or not a foul and yet another error from an error-prone ref....



Not your average Sunday League player.

Reply
7. Author:  pars no1        
Date: Mon 3rd Mar 2025. 18:56

it is only a red card if it was deemed to be violent conduct or a non attempt to play the ball foul. the last man rule changed to no longer a straight red if an attempt to play the ball has been made (which on this occasion it was)



Reply
8. Author:  Parfect69        
Date: Mon 3rd Mar 2025. 19:05

pars no1, Mon 3 Mar 18:56

it is only a red card if it was deemed to be violent conduct or a non attempt to play the ball foul. the last man rule changed to no longer a straight red if an attempt to play the ball has been made (which on this occasion it was)


If that’s the case then it should be definitely be reversed 👍

Reply
9. Author:  DA-go Par Adonis        
Date: Mon 3rd Mar 2025. 19:07

pars no1, Mon 3 Mar 18:56

it is only a red card if it was deemed to be violent conduct or a non attempt to play the ball foul. the last man rule changed to no longer a straight red if an attempt to play the ball has been made (which on this occasion it was)


That`s if the foul results in a penalty.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Equal rights and justice in this time


Reply
10. Author:  sonofpetrie        
Date: Mon 3rd Mar 2025. 19:17

Benny mouthed the words "he was offside" as he left the park. I thought the same on the day and was watching the linesman. He twitched his flag after the first pass but remembered we don`t do that anymore, we let the play run and call it back. By this point the tackle had occurred and the red was in the air. He looked a bit lost but didn`t want to contradict the ref so did nothing. It was a joke from start to finish.

"The only place success comes before work is in the dictionary"

Reply
11. Author:  par-91        
Date: Mon 3rd Mar 2025. 19:19

pars no1, Mon 3 Mar 18:56

it is only a red card if it was deemed to be violent conduct or a non attempt to play the ball foul. the last man rule changed to no longer a straight red if an attempt to play the ball has been made (which on this occasion it was)


That’s not true. Outside of the box, deliberate or not, a denial of a goal scoring opportunity is a red card.

Reply
12. Author:  LochgellyAlbert        
Date: Tue 4th Mar 2025. 00:25

Once again the standard of referreing left a lot to be desired!

Reply
13. Author:  the saline hill puma        
Date: Tue 4th Mar 2025. 07:57

sonofpetrie, Mon 3 Mar 19:17

Benny mouthed the words "he was offside" as he left the park. I thought the same on the day and was watching the linesman. He twitched his flag after the first pass but remembered we don`t do that anymore, we let the play run and call it back. By this point the tackle had occurred and the red was in the air. He looked a bit lost but didn`t want to contradict the ref so did nothing. It was a joke from start to finish.


The decision to delay on offside is only protocol if VAR is involved.
The assistant thought he was onside otherwise they flag straight away.

Post Edited (Tue 04 Mar 11:28)

Reply
14. Author:  Zimbo        
Date: Tue 4th Mar 2025. 08:19

I was right in line with the Morton player and he was a yard offside.

Reply
15. Author:  kelty_par        
Date: Tue 4th Mar 2025. 10:32

It`s amazing how many folk complain about the standard of refereeing yet don`t seem to know the laws of the game...



Reply
16. Author:  Andrew283        
Date: Tue 4th Mar 2025. 10:38

par-91, Mon 3 Mar 19:19

pars no1, Mon 3 Mar 18:56

it is only a red card if it was deemed to be violent conduct or a non attempt to play the ball foul. the last man rule changed to no longer a straight red if an attempt to play the ball has been made (which on this occasion it was)


That’s not true. Outside of the box, deliberate or not, a denial of a goal scoring opportunity is a red card.


This. Still not a red though.

Reply
17. Author:  sonofpetrie        
Date: Tue 4th Mar 2025. 10:52

the saline hill puma, Tue 4 Mar 07:57

sonofpetrie, Mon 3 Mar 19:17

Benny mouthed the words "he was offside" as he left the park. I thought the same on the day and was watching the linesman. He twitched his flag after the first pass but remembered we don`t do that anymore, we let the play run and call it back. By this point the tackle had occurred and the red was in the air. He looked a bit lost but didn`t want to contradict the ref so did nothing. It was a joke from start to finish.


That`s decision to delay on offside is only protocol if VAR is involved.
The assistant thought he was onside otherwise they flag straight away.


I am aware that is the protocol and we don`t have VAR. It was a brain fart on his part. He thought about lifting the flag and started to do so but didn`t in the end.

"The only place success comes before work is in the dictionary"

Reply
18. Author:  par-91        
Date: Tue 4th Mar 2025. 10:54

Andrew283, Tue 4 Mar 10:38

par-91, Mon 3 Mar 19:19

pars no1, Mon 3 Mar 18:56

it is only a red card if it was deemed to be violent conduct or a non attempt to play the ball foul. the last man rule changed to no longer a straight red if an attempt to play the ball has been made (which on this occasion it was)


That’s not true. Outside of the box, deliberate or not, a denial of a goal scoring opportunity is a red card.


This. Still not a red though.


Agreed. For the record, I don’t believe it was a foul. Therefore, not a red card. However, as soon as the referee gave the foul in that situation, there was no other option but to give the red card.

Reply
19. Author:  Bandy        
Date: Tue 4th Mar 2025. 10:59

The offside doesn`t come into the appeal - officially he was onside, so that point is moot.

The only basis for the appeal is that Bene didn`t commit a foul.

The club will know this, so I assume that they have evidence that show conclusively that he played the ball first. The camera angles I`ve seen don`t show this conclusively, so unless we have other angles for the appeal then I don`t hold out much hope for this one.



Reply
20. Author:  wee eck        
Date: Tue 4th Mar 2025. 11:09

Is the ref involved in the appeal? Does he have to admit he made a mistake or is the appeal judged by a panel who weren`t involved in the game?



Reply
     [ 1 ] -- 2 --      

Post your Reply

Your Message:  


By using your account you have implicitly accepted the DAFC.net Forum Rules and agree to be bound by them. You also agree that you will take sole responsibility for your post and indemnify dafc.net on all matters and costs. Refrain from making any potentially libelous comments about anyone
- - -