DAFC.net
Login:

password:  
  



Forum List | Football Forum

     1 -- [ 2 ] -- 3 -- 4 --      

Topic: Referee v Partick 1st leg
21. Author:  twin par        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 01:02

That is a penalty,all day long. I was at the game,and was level with it in main stand.

Post Edited (Wed 13 May 01:03)

Reply
22. Author:  PARrot        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 02:09

twin par, Wed 13 May 01:02

That is a penalty,all day long. I was at the game,and was level with it in main stand.


Im in two minds. The pundits all said outside the box, so a foul.
Im listening but it was very close to the Denmark penalty

Reply
23. Author:  parsmad68        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 05:46

PARrot, Wed 13 May 02:09

twin par, Wed 13 May 01:02

That is a penalty,all day long. I was at the game,and was level with it in main stand.


Im in two minds. The pundits all said outside the box, so a foul.
Im listening but it was very close to the Denmark penalty


It was a stonewall red card irrespective of whether it was inside or outside the box

Reply
24. Author:  Raymie the Legend        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 06:19

No, it wasn’t a red card.




It`s bloody tough being a legend
Ron Atkinson - 1983


Reply
25. Author:  ipswichpar        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 06:35

The officials were awful in both directions last night but we suffered more.

A definitely penalty and booking for me last night. And if it wasn`t a penalty I can`t understand why it wasn`t a booking for simulation.

Ashcroft did enough for a red last night from my view cumulatively (appreciate it might not have happened if the correct early booking was given).

Reply
26. Author:  pacifist        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 07:56

Ashcroft will do anything if he continues to get away with it, which he did. Awful refereeing.



Reply
27. Author:  Pars Athletic        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 08:22

If the foul continues into the box it`s a pen

Reply
28. Author:  Athletico        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 08:39

PARrot, Wed 13 May 02:09

twin par, Wed 13 May 01:02

That is a penalty,all day long. I was at the game,and was level with it in main stand.


Im in two minds. The pundits all said outside the box, so a foul.
Im listening but it was very close to the Denmark penalty


Not true. They said it was a foul, but whether it continues into the box was the question.

Reply
29. Author:  Bandy        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 08:56

Athletico, Wed 13 May 08:39

PARrot, Wed 13 May 02:09

twin par, Wed 13 May 01:02

That is a penalty,all day long. I was at the game,and was level with it in main stand.


Im in two minds. The pundits all said outside the box, so a foul.
Im listening but it was very close to the Denmark penalty


Not true. They said it was a foul, but whether it continues into the box was the question.


Whatever the `right` decision was giving a goal kick was absolutely the worst decision.

A clear, obvious, foul robbed us of a great attacking situation, and the result is thistle getting possession.

Reply
30. Author:  da_no_1        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 09:01

If Thistle go up they better ditch Ashcroft. VAR will shaft him and his antics every week.

"Some days will stay a 1000 years, some pass like the flash of a spark"

Reply
31. Author:  wee eck        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 09:12

You would have thought for an important match like that the SFA would avoid appointing a referee who had `previous` with one of the clubs but I suppose that might imply that the officials weren`t up to standard so wouldn`t happen. Are our refs really as bad as we claim or is that just fans` bias?

I`m keen to see a replay of the Todd incident but so far the only highlights on the BBC Sport website are the goals and they miss the glorious crossfield pass which started the move for our goal.

Reply
32. Author:  king lad        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 09:19

It`s without doubt a foul at the very least and the legs tangle in the box as well. Ashcroft could`ve very easily been off the park in that game if we had a competent referee.

Nicolson has been abysmal every time I`ve seen him, for whatever reason he`s being labelled as an up and coming referee by the SFA. He`s utterly lost in these games and completely inconsistent as well.

Reply
33. Author:  Playup_Pompey        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 09:39

"You would have thought for an important match like that the SFA would avoid appointing a referee who had `previous` with one of the clubs"

as stated above he had "previous" with both where he didnt send off a st johnstone player for a forearm smash on a thistle player where he was subsequently banned by discuiplinary panel. His last match with us there was no "drama" in the 2-0 win at Ayr and awarded us a pen.



Reply
34. Author:  Parsdaft21346327964        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 09:43

Which is actually quite funny because I think the one last night is way more of a pen than the one at Ayr



Reply
35. Author:  Indiapar1        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 10:00

The MattyTodd incident was at least a free kick if not a penalty. We had scored from a similar move earlier so an obvious foul. Ashcroft should have been booked which would have changed his game approach.

G Wardrope

Reply
36. Author:  veteraneastender        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 10:06

wee eck, Wed 13 May 09:12

You would have thought for an important match like that the SFA would avoid appointing a referee who had `previous` with one of the clubs but I suppose that might imply that the officials weren`t up to standard so wouldn`t happen. Are our refs really as bad as we claim or is that just fans` bias?

I`m keen to see a replay of the Todd incident but so far the only highlights on the BBC Sport website are the goals and they miss the glorious crossfield pass which started the move for our goal.


The SFA don’t appoint officials to SPFL fixtures.

Reply
37. Author:  GG Riva        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 10:31

wee eck, Wed 13 May 09:12

You would have thought for an important match like that the SFA would avoid appointing a referee who had `previous` with one of the clubs but I suppose that might imply that the officials weren`t up to standard so wouldn`t happen. Are our refs really as bad as we claim or is that just fans` bias?

I`m keen to see a replay of the Todd incident but so far the only highlights on the BBC Sport website are the goals and they miss the glorious crossfield pass which started the move for our goal.


A slippery slope, wee eck. While I agree that Nicholson was worse than useless, clubs cannot ever be allowed to influence the choice of referee for their games.

Celtic would never want John Beaton
Rangers, Willie Colm, etc.



Not your average Sunday League player.

Reply
38. Author:  wee eck        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 11:14

`The SFA don’t appoint officials to SPFL fixtures.`

I would still make the same pointb regardless of who appoints them.


`A slippery slope, wee eck. While I agree that Nicholson was worse than useless, clubs cannot ever be allowed to influence the choice of referee for their games.`

I wasn`t suggesting clubs should influence the choice of referee. I`d actually be interested to know the factors that do influence the choice of referee. Are they drawn out of a hat?



Reply
39. Author:  parsmad68        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 11:36

wee eck, Wed 13 May 11:14

`The SFA don’t appoint officials to SPFL fixtures.`

I would still make the same pointb regardless of who appoints them.


`A slippery slope, wee eck. While I agree that Nicholson was worse than useless, clubs cannot ever be allowed to influence the choice of referee for their games.`

I wasn`t suggesting clubs should influence the choice of referee. I`d actually be interested to know the factors that do influence the choice of referee. Are they drawn out of a hat?


I think a lucky bag more than a hat would be appropriate.

Reply
40. Author:  Leamington_sPAR        
Date: Wed 13th May 2026. 13:07

PARrot, Wed 13 May 02:09

twin par, Wed 13 May 01:02

That is a penalty,all day long. I was at the game,and was level with it in main stand.


Im in two minds. The pundits all said outside the box, so a foul.
Im listening but it was very close to the Denmark penalty


I believe that if the foul continues into the box it’s deemed a penalty, he clearly had his across his shoulder to impede progress.

Reply
     1 -- [ 2 ] -- 3 -- 4 --      

Post your Reply

Your Message:  


By using your account you have implicitly accepted the DAFC.net Forum Rules and agree to be bound by them. You also agree that you will take sole responsibility for your post and indemnify dafc.net on all matters and costs. Refrain from making any potentially libelous comments about anyone
- - -