Forum List | Football Forum
Start Previous [ 1 ] -- 2 -- 3 -- Next End| Topic: Highlights Partick Thistle + Neil Lennon + Charlie Gilmour |
|---|
| 1. Author: brian Date: Sun 28th Sep 2025. 08:34 [youtube]Vz93SjiQTFA[/youtube] [youtube]lmM2Xur0s1k[/youtube] [youtube]hTWYxr_Hq-M[/youtube] Post Edited (Sun 28 Sep 20:25) Reply |
| 2. Author: bannerpar Date: Sun 28th Sep 2025. 16:54 In the melee at the sending off, Lee Ashcroft and Charlie Gilmour looked as if they were arranging to meet up in the tunnel after the game. Hope they had time to cool down by then! Wonder if we will see any afters from them in future meetings of the sides. Reply |
| 3. Author: onandupthepars Date: Sun 28th Sep 2025. 21:31 Judging by the highlights alone and studying frame by frame, I think Jeff was hard done by wi that red card. The jag was fouling him from first contact, and kept fouling him - he didn`t let go of Jeff`s shirt but yanked him back - and crucially - yanked him so hard it appears he caused them to meet head to head. Lenno was a long way from the incident, but post match he was scathing of Jeff, as if our man was entirely to blame and nutted the jag on purpose. Is anyone absolutely certain there was intent? Otherwise, I thought Lenno was fairly encouraging in his comments, and although I think he was right that our goalie slipped up on the second goal, he omitted to say that he also made two fantastic goal-preventing saves. Post Edited (Sun 28 Sep 21:32) Reply |
| 4. Author: jake89 Date: Sun 28th Sep 2025. 21:40 That was never in a million years a red card. He was pulled into it by the Partick player. I hope it gets appealed as I`m getting pretty fed up of poor referee decisions. Reply |
| 5. Author: Jeffery Date: Sun 28th Sep 2025. 21:49 Looks appealable to me. Other teams are doing a much better job of playing the `game of ref` than we are. Reply |
| 6. Author: Dumpster Date: Sun 28th Sep 2025. 23:16 I’ve watched the sending off incident a few times and to me It looks a sending off all day long, I’m afraid. While Thistle player has hold off Jefferson’s shirt, he knows what he’s doing putting his head into the Thistle player. Reply |
| 7. Author: NMCmassive Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 00:29 I don’t think we’ll appeal that. It is what it is. I hope it’s stung enough that they won’t try and man handle him like that the next time we play COYP Reply |
| 8. Author: parsmad68 Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 07:25 I thought at the time the pulling of the shirt was so strong it unbalanced the player off his feet and he was naturally falling. But I was assured by the people around me it was deliberate. Reply |
| 9. Author: Lesliepartoo Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 08:33 Looks to me in the replay that the partick player pulled him towards him..a thought that at the time too sitting in the north west Cmon ye pars Reply |
| 10. Author: nick_dafc1 Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 08:48 That`s a red all day long. caceres asking for that by putting his head in. Refs may be terrible but that`s one they got correct. Reply |
| 11. Author: MinnesotaAndy Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 08:57 A friend of mine, not into football, pretty much thinks that all the shirt pulling that goes on in football is patently absurd. Personally, I would like to see an attempt to seriously reducing the amount of shirt pulling. VAR could be used for this, with a yellow card for each and every shirt pull. I agree with the manager that the Pars could have taken something from each of the three lost games. Reply |
| 12. Author: jake89 Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 09:13 Maybe need to get skin tight strips for next season. Reply |
| 13. Author: ParfectXI Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 09:23 Those saying it was never a red card or “appealable” are just wishful thinking I’m afraid! Absolute Red card all day long for violent conduct despite the circumstances that the jersey was being pulled! Appealing could have a detrimental effect of increasing the match ban so its right not to go there! Reply |
| 14. Author: Raymie the Legend Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 10:10 It’s a red card all day long. Sorry  It`s bloody tough being a legend Ron Atkinson - 1983 Reply |
| 15. Author: Raymie the Legend Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 10:15 I wasn’t able to see the game on Saturday, so just watched the highlights With regard to the second goal, I have some sympathy with the goalie. I’m not sure he was at fault too much. For me, Fraser was more culpable. Mistake one was allowing Chalmers to come in on his strong side. Mistake two was turning 360 degrees and therefore not sure where the ball was. I have to agree with Lennon in respect that we got into several good positions in the first half, but a combination of poor finishing, bad decision making and not getting a wee rub of the green, meant we couldn’t score. It`s bloody tough being a legend Ron Atkinson - 1983 Post Edited (Mon 29 Sep 10:15) Reply |
| 16. Author: LochgellyAlbert Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 11:17 We had 4/5 chances that should have been taken! Reply |
| 17. Author: allanwilson10 Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 11:53 Red card all day long - however, if the ref had done his job properly and gave us the free kick for the shirt pulling, it might never have happened. To award Partick the free kick was ridiculous. Reply |
| 18. Author: kelty_par Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 13:16 A shame there wasn`t a clearer angle on Kane being hauled back when he was about to nod it into the empty net following Cáceres` shot being blocked. He was going mental at the time hut no other player appealed. Certainly looks like he was being pulled by the collar although he should have been stronger and held off his man. There is an angle of the melee from the Partick end which shows that Gilmour was booked for nothing snd that their number 14 (don`t have a team sheet handy) aimed at kick at Amade. Sadly the ref didn`t see this as he was to busy showing Cáceres the red card. Was poor refereeing I thought - he should have ensured all the handbags were put away first before dealing with the Peruvian. Also can see why folk think he was hard done by - looks as though he was pulled back with two hands and that may have caused him to go into O`Reilly. Really hard to make out if he then angles his head in or of it was just a natural reaction but despite it looking harsh, I don`t think we`d win an appeal. Reply |
| 19. Author: GJS93 Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 13:21 ^^  Post Edited (Wed 01 Oct 14:34) Reply |
| 20. Author: Bandy Date: Mon 29th Sep 2025. 13:39 So. Clear foul. There`s no excuse for the ref not seeing that. Kane`s naked back is visible. No attempt to the play ball. Clear goalscoring opportunity. That`s a penalty and red. Clear as day. Complete incompetence. Reply |
Post your Reply
Your Message:
By using your account you have implicitly accepted the DAFC.net Forum Rules and agree to be bound by them. You also agree that you will take sole responsibility for your post and indemnify dafc.net on all matters and costs. Refrain from making any potentially libelous comments about anyone
- - -